Simons Pizzeria in Coastal Soutd Carolina

Simons Pizzeria in Coastal Soutd Carolina
3.5 / 5
50 reviews

4030 River Oaks Dr Myrtle Beach, SC 29579, Coastal Soutd Carolina

Overview

Restaurant Hours

Monday

08:00 - 17:00

Tuesday

08:00 - 17:00

Wednesday

08:00 - 17:00

Thursday

00:00 - 17:00

Friday

00:00 - 17:00

Do you have wine and beer?

BYOBB

Review

Add rating restaurant:
Simons Pizzeria
SZ
Sara Zilinsky
google
05.11.2021
5/5

If you haven't been here yet, it's a must-try! The piea are huge and heavy, and the crust is awesome. Seriously the best pie I have had in years. Thanks for making our dinner tonight!

Simons Pizzeria
DE
David Eichen
google
10.08.2018
5/5

Family owned and operated we known them for many years in nj now they brought that great food here go try it's the best you wont regret it

Simons Pizzeria
JW
John Winzenried
google
09.15.2018
5/5

WOW, great food. I have been ordering different foods off the menu and have been pleased. I have had the Sausage roll, Meatball sub, Sicilian Pizza, lunch special 2 slices and drink, Italian sub, Chicken Parmesan subs.

Simons Pizzeria
JJ
Jessica Jones
google
07.20.2018
5/5

Scotto's doesn't let you down! Pizza is great, just like back home in NJ. Highly recommend. I was so excited for pizza I took my slice before I took the photo of the pie.

Simons Pizzeria
JG
Joshua Goulding
google
07.11.2018
5/5

Great place to eat, will definitely be back.

Simons Pizzeria
MF
Michael Falvo
google
06.24.2018
5/5

I had such a wonderful experience here. The staff was so friendly, very attentive, and the food was amazing. The restaurant was very clean, it had a great atmosphere. The owners are really doing a great job. This restaurant is going to be a hit in the Carolina Forest community. If you want great food and great service. This is the new hot spot in the area.

Simons Pizzeria
JT
Javier Torres
google
06.16.2018
5/5

Fantastic.. best pizza so far. Jersey Style.. I love it

Simons Pizzeria
MC
Michael Cahill
google
05.02.2018
1/5

Good pizza but tried calling 3x and was put on an automated voice message hold for 10 minutes each time. Guess they need more help answering phones! Michaels pizza got my business tonight! Just as good.

Simons Pizzeria
LJ
Layla Johnson
google
04.11.2018
5/5

Best pizza we’ve ever had! You will not be disappointed!

Simons Pizzeria
kh
kelly hoenscheid
google
04.09.2018
5/5

Loved it! Great food & warm staff make up for lack of ambience strip mall location. I enjoyedtheir chef salad stacked high with turkey/ham, cheese, marinated red bell pepper & cucumber on real greens (not nasty iceberg)! Home made vinaigrette dressing is lovely. Pizza is a yummy NY style. Not your run of the mill pizzeria. Give them your business, no regrets!!!!

Simons Pizzeria
JM
James McGinn
google
03.23.2018
2/5

Nothing special about the Philly special. Not many onions, peppers or mushrooms.

Simons Pizzeria
CG
Carolyn Gallo
google
02.11.2018
3/5

Pizza just okay. Crust too crispy

Simons Pizzeria
CB
Carla Baker
google
01.25.2018
5/5

The food and the service is amazing!! Everyone that works there is so super friendly and always so professional. You honestly get treated like you are family. Keep up the great work!!

Simons Pizzeria
KH
Keith Hinkley
google
01.22.2018
5/5

Great pie, great calzone and great staff. If only we could get past those 2 things ?

Simons Pizzeria
JG
Josh Griffith
google
11.03.2017
5/5

Best pizza in town! The service was friendly and prompt!

Simons Pizzeria
SC
Sandy Cramer
google
10.26.2017
5/5

Finally a great pizza place! Originally from NJ I have been searching for good pizza. I knew they would be good since they are also from NJ. I had their pizza, meatball sub and Italian sub so far and all were excellent!! Thank you for moving to the beach! It’s a taste of home to me.

Simons Pizzeria
JM
Jana Mckenzie
google
10.08.2017
5/5

Hands down the best pizza in MB. I don't trust 5 star reviews in MB when it comes to food bc people come from everywhere. I am from NY/NJ and I know good food and good pizza. This is GOOD pizza.

Simons Pizzeria
JP
Joe Procopio
google
10.07.2017
5/5

Just like Jersey pizza... Crispy crust, not thick, just right.

Simons Pizzeria
RK
Raymond Krautheim
google
07.01.2017
4/5

Cheese steak pizza and plain pizza were good. Thin crust. friendly staff

Simons Pizzeria
NM
Nicholas Marsico
google
06.24.2017
5/5

Best pizza in town. It’s not even close. Finally pizza that tastes like I’m back home in NJ/NY. Great friendly staff as well. Love the place!!

Simons Pizzeria
TV
T Van485
google
03.22.2017
5/5

Very good pizza and the atmosphere is that of a hometown restaurant. Regulars are acknowledged and treated as such. And, new customers are very appreciatiated.

Simons Pizzeria
SP
Sal Pavone
google
03.12.2017
5/5

I want to thank Scotto family for helping us through these hard times not only is the food good but the family is outstanding always polite courteous and friendly thanks again for everything you do for the community let’s help support this restaurant through these tough times we need them (che Dio vi benedica)

Simons Pizzeria
DC
DonnaMarie Cipolla
google
02.21.2017
5/5

Have eaten there and did take out many times. The other night we decided to try the sausage and pepper roll...it was amazing, don't know how they do the sausage but it was the texture of shaved steak but the best tasting Italian sausage. It was packed solid with peppers and cheese and absolutely delicious

Simons Pizzeria
TR
Tammy Ryan
google
02.13.2017
5/5

First time there. Got a pepperoni roll and my boyfriend got a calzone and they were both huge and amazing.

Simons Pizzeria
SF
Shawn Flanagan
google
02.12.2017
5/5

Great place to eat.. great service and amazing food..

Simons Pizzeria
PK
Peter Kim
google
01.11.2017
5/5

Awesome place to go for pizza. Great service!

Simons Pizzeria
EM
Elizabeth Mack
google
11.03.2016
5/5

Consistently great food and the owners and staff are so helpful. Try to go every week.

Simons Pizzeria
JS
Jessica Skibicki
google
10.13.2016
5/5

I absolutely loved this place today!! FINALLY a place that tastes like the pizza back home from PA! The staff was so incredibly kind! They were so thoughtful that they even cut up a slice of pizza for my 1 yr old! Very family friendly atmosphere with outstanding food!! Definitely give it a try! Don’t pay attention to negative reviews... not 1 person in there was rude and the customers were giving nothing but compliments to the staff! Can’t wait to return and try more of the items they offer!

Simons Pizzeria
RM
Rhonda Marchetti
google
09.25.2016
5/5

If your looking for a great pie,this family owned shop from Jersey which is the best place if looking for a true Italian cuisine.

Simons Pizzeria
JJ
Joey J
google
09.14.2016
5/5

I am speechless, I have yet to find a pizza place to even compare to NY in a long time to top it off the wings are the best I’ve had also. This place is beyond good Deff my goto spot from here on out very impressed!

Simons Pizzeria
SM
Steven Mack
google
08.27.2016
5/5

We have made our visit to Scotto’s a weekly event and thankful they are so convenient to Carolina Forest. Trying several menu items we have found everything delicious although personal favorites are Pasta with broccoli, oil, garlic and chicken as well as Chicken Lina and of course the Pizza. Deserving of a 10! 👍

Simons Pizzeria
LT
Lisa Thaxton
google
07.21.2016
5/5

Coming from West Virginia, I have to say, this is the BEST Pizza place I have ever ate at in my entire life!!! You definitely have to try this place! we will return every time! fun and friendly atmosphere, A++++

Simons Pizzeria
Gm
Gena marie
google
07.17.2016
5/5

Amazing authentic New York style pizzaBest pizza around hands down Call your order in and ready when you pick upHighly recommend them

Simons Pizzeria
RD
Ron Danshire
google
07.15.2016
5/5

Just outstanding thin crust pizza. Great flavors from every ingredient. I did try their subs. I’mNot a fan. Just weak all around. However I’m not taking that away from my rating. This place rocks and is now ( in my opinion) the best of the beach

Simons Pizzeria
tw
tommy wood
google
07.15.2016
5/5

The staff here is extremely friendly and the food is amazing! My family had a variety of dishes after church and we all enjoyed the experience very much.

Simons Pizzeria
HM
Heather Milonas
google
06.25.2016
5/5

The best authentic Italian Pizzeria in Myrtle Beach with many years experience in the business! Just like back home in NJ/NY and a very nice Italian family too! They even have cannoli's (filled to order) and homemade cheesecake too!

Simons Pizzeria
TK
Tim Keh
google
06.11.2016
5/5

Awesome the best pizza around the people are great and good prices you don't leave hungry👍

Simons Pizzeria
JB
Jordan Baker
google
05.25.2016
5/5

I am 'bout to shout! I have never had a better calzone. The ricotta cheese is superb. Plenty of ingredients. And it is ENORMOUS. I really tried to limit myself but I kept sneaking back for a bite. The sauce is really good...I should have gotten extra. The menu is extensive for a small place and I can't wait to try it all. The inside is clean, updated and smells incredible. They took my order late (right before they closed)and were super fast. I really like to see young people making a business flourish. I love this new edition to Carolina Forest.

Simons Pizzeria
gc
glen carr
google
05.24.2016
5/5

Just like ny or nj pizzeria. Outstanding!

Simons Pizzeria
NW
Nancy Williams
google
04.13.2016
5/5

Best pizza in Myrtle Beach! Cheesesteaks and pasta also excellent, and they make you feel like family!

Simons Pizzeria
CD
Carol Drinkwater
google
04.06.2016
5/5

After hearing many great things about Scotto’s I finally tried them out. Ordered a chicken roll ( these guys are definitely from up north ) they knew what that is. Staff polite and friendly. Oh I almost forgot, BEST chicken roll I ever had!!! Being from LI I’ve eaten a lot of chicken rolls. Tried the pizza and it was GREAT! Will for sure be back for great food. Good luck with your business.

Simons Pizzeria
FM
Frank Marchisella
google
04.05.2016
5/5

Very good pizza deal..two slices and a drink for under 8 bucks

Simons Pizzeria
LO
Lori Olson
google
04.03.2016
5/5

We had a pepperoni & mushroom pizza and an antipasto salad. It was all delicious. Lots of toppings on pizza and salad. Highly recommend

Simons Pizzeria
TS
Tony Scotto
google
03.23.2016
5/5

Great People! Great Food!

Simons Pizzeria
KA
Kim Akins
google
03.22.2016
5/5

Pizza and garlic knots were wonderful. It did take about 30 minutes to get our pizza but it was worth the wait.

Simons Pizzeria
TM
Teresa Moore
google
03.13.2016
2/5

I had family over last night. I ordered 2 pizzas 2 regular salads and a sandwich. I have ordered several times before. The pizzas were tasteless. The salads were just a bunch of stuff threw together. There were a hand full of jar red peppers on top which saturated everything. The olives were mushy. I was really embarrassed and surprised. What in the world?

Simons Pizzeria
MB
M B
google
02.17.2016
5/5

Best pizza in MB area! Order 3x weekly and always on point. Pizza is REAL italian pizza & calzones are also really good. We order alot from scottos & always on point. Good food , good prices & nice people. Very Clean restaurant. They should get 10+ stars!!

Simons Pizzeria
BR
Barbara Runion
google
01.24.2016
1/5

We've previously tried Scotto's pizza. Not so great. Today we ordered what will be our last pizza from Scotto's. The 2"-3" crust around the edges was burnt and very hard/tough. Inedible. You could barely take a bite out of the pizza or cut it into slices because the bottom crust was so hardened. The pepperoni was also burnt around the edges. The tomato sauce and cheese on the pizza was microscopically thin. I don't know how anyone can make a living selling such poor quality pizza. It was an insult. We so hoped today's pizza would be better than the previous and would like to see Scotto's Pizzeria in Carolina Forest survive and thrive. At this rate unless improvements are made with their pizza Scotto's is doomed to fail. I've been eating pizza for over 50 years and today's from Scotto's was the worst pizza I've ever eaten and that is the honest truth.

Simons Pizzeria
TM
Tom Maj
google
01.13.2016
5/5

Excellent pies! This pizza joint will be in my regular rotation of places when I visit Myrtle. I’ll update with pics next time. Don’t let the prices scare you, you get what you pay for. The large pies are HUGE. A big eater would have a hard time finishing 3 slices.

Simons Pizzeria
LL
Larry Long
google
01.10.2016
1/5

Just ok not worth 34.00 for small calzone and lg 2item pizza owner even worse only orderd sm calzone with pep and sauage didnt order conola and never got either so if we were charge that thats on u

Your question has been sent.

Expect an answer!

Thank!

Your review has been submitted.

Order food

Reservation

Want to order over the phone?

Call 18439036166

Thank you for being with us!

We will call you back!